Wells Debutant Franco Mici made sure the points were shared with a 90th min equaliser at The Culverden.
Sheppey took the lead on 30mins when Remel Davis converted was left unmarked from a corner kick to fire home.
Mici however sent the Home fans into the festive break with a smile on their faces when he drilled Home through a busy area.
Next up The Wells travel up the A26 to face title contenders Crowborough Athletic.
Kick Off 3pm.