The Wells were held to a draw away to Surrey based Knaphill in the second qualifying round of the FA Vase.
Knaphill took the lead after 12mins when Matt Bunyan tapped home a rebounded effort.
Euan Sahadow drew The Wells level from the penalty spot on the stroke of half time after Danny Powell was fouled just as he was to score.
Knaphill were reduced to ten men a few moments later when Jay Welch saw a straight red for a dangerous challenge on Euan Sahadow.
The Wells extra man advantage disappeared when Chris Lawal got his marching orders for a second bookable offence.
The Wells took the lead on 65mins when Jake Beecroft went past 3 defenders and rifled home his strike from 20 yards.
Kane Fitzgerald equalised for the hosts with 4mins remaining to send the game to extra time.
Despite Knaphill having the better chances in extra time a winner could not be found and the sides will meet again in the replay on Tuesday evening at The Culverden.
Kick Off 7:45pm
RICHARD STYLES REACTION - 10 men, 2 players injured but after just missing out on finishing the tie in 90 mins, the Tunbridge Wells boys dug in and ground out a draw for a replay on Tuesday. Can’t fault the efforts and commitment levels shown from the boys.
Thanks to all TWFC supporters that made the journey
Onto Tuesday now