The Wells crashed out of the FA Vase after being dismantled by a ruthless Sheppey Utd.
The Wells found themselves a goal down after the Ites first attack and two down after 18mins.
Thoughts of a spirited comeback were short lived after Jonny Pilbeam pulled a goal back early in the second half.
Sheppey proceeded to go on a scoring spree and will now host Fisher in the next round.
The Wells must dust themselves down when they return to league action on Saturday away to Canterbury City.
A thrilling opening game of this seasons FA Vase saw The Wells play out a 2-2 draw with hosts Sheppey Utd.
The Wells found themselves a goal down after 5mins after Luke Girt sublime 25yrd long range effort.
The Wells rallied after half time and added more urgency to their game and were rewarded with an equaliser when Kieron Tarbie's shot could only be parried by the Ites goalkeeper and Jack Harris found the net.
A thrilling game encounter saw The Wells somehow leave the Mayfield stadium without any points.
The Rams took the lead only for a Joe Nwoko to equalise before Jake Beecroft scored a penalty to give The Wells the lead.
Croydon however would have the final say as they equalised and secured the win with a penalty after Tom Davey saw red.
Next Up The Wells travel to Sheppey Utd on Saturday for the beginning of this seasons FA Vase.
The Wells bowed out of this seasons FA Cup at the hands of Conference South side Concord Rangers.
The Wells found themselves 3-0 down after 15mins and 4-0 after 37mins.
Despite a spirited second half display The Wells could find no way back.
Next up The Wells travel to the Mayfield Stadium to face AFC Croydon Athletic on Tuesday evening.